We rated every player on the 2005 Cincinnati Bengalsagainst their own era and built their best 12-man roster. Here's how strong this squad really was — and whether it could chase a perfect 20-0.
One player per slot, chosen by our era-relative rating. This is the lineup that sets the projection above.
Every rating is era-relative: a player is graded against their own era's peers at the same position, with impact plays counting most and an All-Pro boost. The roster rating is the position-weighted strength of the best 12 — premium spots (QB, edge, corner) count for more, and a single weak link drags the average down. Only a near-flawless roster projects to run the table. Full method →
An independent fan project. Player ratings are our own derivation from public statistics. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any professional sports league, team, or player.