Roster ratings

Can the 2024 Detroit Lions go 20-0?

We rated every player on the 2024 Detroit Lionsagainst their own era and built their best 12-man roster. Here's how strong this squad really was — and whether it could chase a perfect 20-0.

87.3Roster rating /100
#9All-time rank of 861
A genuine 20-0 contenderOur verdict
▶ Play the Lions yourself

The best 12 — our all-time picks from this squad

One player per slot, chosen by our era-relative rating. This is the lineup that sets the projection above.

Offense

QBJared Goff91
RBJahmyr Gibbs99
WRAmon-Ra St. Brown ★AP99
TESam LaPorta83
WRJameson Williams80
RBDavid Montgomery75

Defense

EDGEZa'Darius Smith81
DTAlim McNeill78
LBJack Campbell83
CBCarlton Davis III82
SKerby Joseph ★AP99
SBrian Branch ★AP98

How we rate it

Every rating is era-relative: a player is graded against their own era's peers at the same position, with impact plays counting most and an All-Pro boost. The roster rating is the position-weighted strength of the best 12 — premium spots (QB, edge, corner) count for more, and a single weak link drags the average down. Only a near-flawless roster projects to run the table. Full method →

Other rated Lions seasons

An independent fan project. Player ratings are our own derivation from public statistics. Not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any professional sports league, team, or player.